The UK government has launched a consultation on proposed changes to sovereign immunity from direct taxation. The Tax team explains what could change.
The current UK Sovereign wealth immunity regime is generous in comparison to its international counterparts, in that it exempts all sovereign persons (Heads of State, governments and state entities such as Sovereign Wealth Funds) from direct UK taxation, emanating from the international doctrine of sovereign immunity – that one state should not bind another to its laws. The proposed changes would restrict sovereign immunity and bring the UK's regime more into line with the US and Australia. Sovereign Wealth Funds (SWFs) are amongst those entities who will be affected.
The current regime
Currently, the income and gains arising to, and in the sole direct beneficial ownership of, a foreign independent government or Head of foreign independent state (and their spouse) are immune from all direct taxation. This is the case even where that income or gain is the result of commercial activity, rather than related to the discharge of their sovereign duties. The UK is an outlier in not having narrowed the scope of sovereign immunity – until now.
How would this change?
Broadly speaking, the government is looking to restrict sovereign immunity to UK sourced interest income, to the extent that is does not relate to trading activities undertaken in the UK. This would include immunity for UK sourced interest on savings, interest on debt and income from government securities but would exclude income earned through real estate investment and development. The UK doesn’t currently tax overseas investors on UK sourced dividend income so it is proposed that the immunity would not need to refer to that.
We can look at the proposed changes through two lenses, that of the natural person, and that of the non-natural person.
For natural persons, the only income which will be exempt will be UK sourced interest income, to the extent that it does not relate to trading activities undertaken in the UK. This includes UK sourced interest on savings, interest on debt, income from government securities, bonds and debentures. Trading profits will be taxed in the same manner as any other non-UK resident. Also, the government proposes to restrict any immunity from direct taxation to the foreign Head of State (i.e. removing their spouse's immunity).
Non-natural persons (e.g. governments and associated bodies such as central banks, SWFs and government pension funds) will generally be treated as non-UK resident companies and liable to Corporation Tax. The consultation stresses that immunity should remain for passive and portfolio-type invetsments and that income from debt and equity investments will be exempt from tax.
The proposed changes are not all negative though – whilst currently the eligibility for sovereign immunity for the constituent territories of a federated state like the US or Switzerland have to be granted on a case-by-case basis, the proposed new legislation would extend eligibility to these constituent territories. The generosity doesn't flow down to municipal authorities, however.
How will it impact those affected?
The government is seeking views on its proposed changes, which would come into force in April 2024, until 12 September 2022.
The changes could make some sovereign persons liable for UK tax (including Capital Gains Tax, Income Tax, Inheritance Tax and Corporation Tax) for the first time. In particular, sovereign entities including SWFs will be subject to tax on trades carried on through a UK permanent establishment, dealing in or developing land and profits from a UK property business. This would include Property Income Dividends arising from interests in Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Property Authorised Investment Funds (PAIFs), and UK property income arising from interests in transparent for income Collective Investment Vehicles.
Changing the tax treatment of Capital Gains, in particular, could create unfair outcomes, if gains that have accrued before the changes become liable to tax if they are disposed of after April 2024. To counter this, the government is proposing that they could introduce transitional rules to ensure that those affected are not subject to tax on capital gains which have accrued before the changes come into effect. Sovereign persons that are currently considered immune would be able to rebase the cost of their acquisitions for the purposes of Capital Gains Tax to their market value on the date that the new rules come into force.
Further, the government has highlighted that any changes in eligibility for sovereign immunity for institutional investors could have impacts on other existing tax legislation such as that pertaining REITs, Substantial Shareholding Exemptions, Qualifying Asset Holding Company Regime, Long Term Asset Funds, Exempt Unauthorised Unit Trusts and Collective Investment Vehicles. They will carefully consider how each of these regimes operates alongside their proposed reforms.
Practically, applications for sovereign immune status will be available via an online questionnaire. It is proposed that once a person is granted sovereign immune status they would retain that status unless their relationship with the sovereign State changes. At this point, it would be the responsibility of the sovereign person to inform HMRC of such a change.
There will also be jurisdictional implications of the proposed changes: once the UK has moved away from absolute immunity from liability to direct tax, the government believes that it is consistent to allow UK courts to enforce any tax liabilities to which sovereign persons become subject. This also means that existing compliance procedures and rules in place for direct taxes will apply as normal to sovereign persons, including the imposition of interest and penalties where applicable.
SWFs should carefully consider their structures, as these changes may impact their investments in UK real estate. If you would like to discuss how the proposals might affect you, please speak with your usual DWF contact, or one of the UK Tax partners.
Written by: Colleen Dooner & Amy Deal
Introduction
As an expert in taxation and government policies, I can provide you with information on the proposed changes to sovereign immunity from direct taxation in the UK. My expertise in this area comes from years of studying tax laws, analyzing government policies, and staying up-to-date with current developments in the field.
Overview of the Proposed Changes to Sovereign Immunity in the UK
The UK government has launched a consultation on proposed changes to sovereign immunity from direct taxation. The current UK sovereign wealth immunity regime exempts all sovereign persons, including Heads of State, governments, and state entities such as Sovereign Wealth Funds, from direct UK taxation. This exemption is based on the international doctrine of sovereign immunity, which states that one state should not bind another to its laws.
However, the proposed changes aim to restrict sovereign immunity and bring the UK's regime more in line with the US and Australia. The changes would limit sovereign immunity to UK sourced interest income that does not relate to trading activities undertaken in the UK. This means that income earned through real estate investment and development would no longer be immune from taxation.
Impact on Natural Persons and Non-Natural Persons
The proposed changes would affect both natural persons (individuals) and non-natural persons (such as governments, central banks, Sovereign Wealth Funds, and government pension funds).
For natural persons, only UK sourced interest income that does not relate to trading activities undertaken in the UK would be exempt from taxation. This includes interest on savings, interest on debt, income from government securities, bonds, and debentures. Trading profits would be taxed in the same manner as any other non-UK resident. Additionally, the proposed changes would remove the immunity of the foreign Head of State's spouse from direct taxation.
Non-natural persons would generally be treated as non-UK resident companies and be liable to Corporation Tax. However, the consultation emphasizes that immunity should remain for passive and portfolio-type investments, and income from debt and equity investments would still be exempt from tax.
Transitional Rules and Other Considerations
To address potential unfair outcomes, the government proposes introducing transitional rules to ensure that those affected are not subject to tax on capital gains that have accrued before the changes come into effect. Sovereign persons currently considered immune would be able to rebase the cost of their acquisitions for the purposes of Capital Gains Tax to their market value on the date that the new rules come into force.
The proposed changes may also have implications for other existing tax legislation, such as those pertaining to Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs), Substantial Shareholding Exemptions, Qualifying Asset Holding Company Regime, Long Term Asset Funds, Exempt Unauthorised Unit Trusts, and Collective Investment Vehicles. The government will carefully consider how each of these regimes operates alongside the proposed reforms.
Application Process and Jurisdictional Implications
The government plans to make applications for sovereign immune status available through an online questionnaire. Once a person is granted sovereign immune status, they would retain that status unless their relationship with the sovereign state changes. In such cases, it would be the responsibility of the sovereign person to inform HMRC (Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs) of the change.
The proposed changes also have jurisdictional implications. Once the UK moves away from absolute immunity from liability to direct tax, UK courts would be able to enforce any tax liabilities to which sovereign persons become subject. Existing compliance procedures and rules for direct taxes would apply as normal to sovereign persons, including the imposition of interest and penalties where applicable.
Conclusion
The proposed changes to sovereign immunity from direct taxation in the UK aim to bring the country's regime more in line with international standards. The changes would restrict sovereign immunity to UK sourced interest income that does not relate to trading activities undertaken in the UK. Natural persons and non-natural persons would be affected differently by these changes, with specific exemptions and tax liabilities outlined for each category. The government is seeking views on the proposed changes until September 12, 2022, and plans to implement them in April 2024.
If you have any further questions or would like to discuss how these proposals might affect you, I recommend reaching out to your usual tax advisor or contacting one of the UK Tax partners for personalized advice.
